Sunday, January 29, 2017
Dinner for Thinkers
Tonight for dinner I'll be having both Noah Charney, The author of "This is your brain on art : A neuroscientist's lessons on why abstract art makes our brains hurt so good", and Jill Bolte Taylor, a brain researcher who talked about her unique experiences she had when suffering from a stroke on the world renowned "TED" talks. Noah Charney an art historian and novelist discusses in his article how he sees art through his observations and art crime background. He explains that the reason abstract art is such a challenge is because it teaches us how to view art and even the world in a new way. He then compares top down thinking to bottom up thinking. Top down thinking being where we use what we know to solve problems and bottom up thinking requiring no apriori thinking or prior knowledge. On the other side of the perspective you've got Jill Bolte Taylor, a woman who values her personal experience the most. In her TED talk, she discusses how the right hemisphere of the brain controls spatial abilities and the left side deals in language. Jill Bolte Taylor goes on to explain the feeling and experience she had when she lost the left side of her brain the morning she had a stroke. Both Noah Charney and Jill Bolte Taylor experienced something new. Noah Charney saw a new way to look at art a different perspective that taught him how to look at not just art but the whole world differently. Jill Bolte Taylor lost parts of her left side of her brain and talked about how she experienced what it was like to just see the world through the right side of her brain and how she saw the world to be completely different. In my opinion, I believe these two scholars would discuss the different ways they've come to see the world through these new experiences, but they would for the most part keep the night pleasant.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I feel like overall I would agree with both sides of what they are saying. I can see how their experiences and what has happened to them shapes their view on the world. I would tell them however that I mostly agree with what Charney is saying because I like to look at the world and take into perspective other peoples views. I like to be able to see things the way other people see them so that way I get a sense of what they are feeling and take it into consideration. While I think that Taylor also makes a good observation, I just feel like I can connect more with Charneys way of thinking about the world.
ReplyDeleteIn a dinner setting such as this I believe I would have a better and more stimulating conversation with Charney, and that it would be easier to participate and add my own thoughts. Speaking with Jill Taylor would would be enjoyable just to hear her talk about her experiences during her stroke, but I would not be able to connect with her or her experiences. I would enjoy talking to both of them but have more input with Charney, even though I think I would enjoy listening to Jill more.
ReplyDelete